Honest Company

Huggies gave my bay horrible chemical burns. It was a nightmare. Pampers didn't help the situation neither did mama bear/members mark/parents choice/luvs or literally any other brand I tried. Honest is the best diapers I swear by them my baby had chemical burns for weeks. He was fire truck red but within 2 days of using honest diapers my baby's but was back normal!! They are expensive but so so worth it

Honest wipes are the best imo. They are sturdy and clean up #2 so much better than any other brand I've tried including water wipes. They are easy to open and close

Clean Conscious Wipes from The Honest Company. These are just about the only wipes I've used since my little one was born, and I just love how gentle and effective they are on her sensitive skin. We order them online from Little Canadian and keep them stocked up at home and in the diaper bag for easy access wherever we go. Not to mention, they're affordable, fragrence free, don't rip, and are plant based + compostable

I think you should consider Ecopea. Then try Milly Moon if you have a super heavy wetter or blowout issues. I've tried 80% of the brands on your list. They were on a short list of brands that could handle a lot of liquid. Those two also fit a tall and chunky baby well. Dyper also was great but it's so expensive. Terra is absorbent but too bulky. I think Pura, Bamboo Nature and Eco by Naty are all great for a 1 year old. But absorption wise I would rank them at the top. For overnight diapers, Honest is the best. Nothing beats them. Whatever you do, don't bother with Hello Bello those diapers are inexpensive but the absorption is the absolute worst.

I love honest brand. They come out of the pack well, they're a good size and dampness level, and the texture is helpful when wiping. They've never given us any issues. I liked water wipes but they're a nightmare to get out of the pack.

Honest Wipes are so good! You know they're good when I asked my husband what his favorite wipes have been (our baby is just about 8 weeks so we've been trying all the brands that have been gifted to us) and he said Honest Wipes lol

I really love my Honest diaper subscription. Only have had a few leaks. The wipes are good too and we are using their zinc spray so I don't have to think about diapering supplies. They just show up when I need them.

Honest works great with no issues. You might need to go up a Size early if you notice leaking. The overnight diapers are incredible.

I've been using honest wipes for about 4 years and love them

We've done really well with Honest. They fit my skinny baby really well. They're not as absorbent as some others like Millie Moon (haven't tried Coterie) so we often use Honest during the day and Millie Moon at night. Honest also fits my baby best when we're sort of between sizes. I'd get small boxes of a few brands before your baby arrives because you never know what will fit. I found Honest newborn to be really small, which was perfect for my sub-7 lbs girl. But we quickly outgrew them. Whereas some other newborn diapers were huge on her at first!

We like Honest Wipes. My baby has very sensitive skin and they don't bother him at all. They're pricier, but worth it to avoid diaper rash.

I like millie moons, but rascal and friends have my baby a rash, she is very very sensitive to diapers. Pampers made her bum bleed, it was really scary tbh. I didn't understand why her diaper rash was so bad I was changing her every 30 minutes and it was so raw then I stopped the pampers and started using Hello Bello and she was fine. I use Hello Bello, Dyper, Huggies or Millie Moon now depending on what's on sale where I'm buying. No cheaper diaper for my lil babes special bum bums. I've also tried Honest baby and they are so cute and don't get her irritated but just way too expensive when there are other options that also don't irritate her!

Based on your list, here are my thoughts: Water wipe is my favorite wipe for at home because the wipe feels super smooth and durable but they don't travel well because of the package type. The only reason I don't buy them for "at home" use is because they're expensive and you can't get them as a refill so there's more plastic waste. For traveling I'd use Honest. They're also a decent wipe but they have a plastic closure on the package. The only weird thing about honest is for some reason you can never get just one out of the package. You either have to dig to get one or you get 2 or 3 at a time. What did I actually use? Huggies Natural Care Sensitive Baby Wipes Refill. They come in a big plastic bag so there's less waste and I put them in my wipes warmer at home. For traveling, I mostly use the Kirkland brand. They're big wipes and really durable but I've also used honest for travel when I get their diaper bundles. As you've probably noticed I'm focused on how well the wipe fits my lifestyle vs what's in the wipes. Sometimes I float between brands depending on what's on sale but I always use Huggies refill at home to reduce waste. If you're seriously concerned about what to buy get a small pack of all of them and see which one fits your lifestyle.

Facts!! I will say- we tried honest diapers once and hated them. They definitely don't stand up overnight for the amount of pee they need to hold! 😅

I was surprised how much I love Huggies. I wanted to love Honest Co, but they leak SO much. It's like they have the lowest capacity for pee. I have to put my son in Huggies overnight or he will definitely pee through the Honest diapers. Millie Moon fits weird, like they're really short and wide. No issues with leaks though.

I just use Huggies. They're a lot like pampers. It's annoying so many come out but it's not the biggest deal. Sometimes I need a lot anyways or I can just shove them back in. They don't dry out really easily so I like that. I've had bad luck with Honest wipes having mold on them, so even though I love their diapers, I don't get their wipes.

Used those and honest wash and lotion and it broke my baby out like mad. Had lil red pimples over his whole body :(

I started with Honest wipes and around 4m my daughter got a rash that I couldn't resolve. Lasted over a month. It was the damn wipes. Switched to Water Wipes, never had a problem again. When my cousin's baby hit 4m, they also developed a rash that wouldn't heal from the Honest wipes!! They're SO DRYING!

I've tested a bunch through the years of baby sitting. I've landed on Millie Moon water wipes! Great, gentle ingredients. Strong but not rough texture. They're amazing. Water Wipes are good too in a pinch but I feel like the Millie Moon ones just clean better. If your baby has sensitive skin, definitely stay clear of the Honest sensitive wipes. Gave my daughter the worst rash ever. Raw open sores. Just awful.