WaterWipes

Lol I actually did this when my wife was pregnant! Tested like 5 different brands on my hands and face to see which ones felt the softest and didn't leave that weird filmy residue. Figured if it felt good on my skin it'd probably be gentler on baby's too Turns out my top pick (Water Wipes) ended up being the only ones that didn't give my daughter a rash, so maybe there's something to it

I have been in early intervention for 15 years and WaterWipes are my favorite. They stay wet so much longer than the other brands and I've never had issues with skin sensitivity.

I worked in daycares and preschools for a decade and now am a mother to a 21 month old with another on the way. I've used a bunch of different wipes on a bunch of different kids and WaterWipes are by far my favorite. They get the mess off effectively but don't contain harsh things like alcohol that will hurt a baby's already sore bum.

I love our water wipes. I would recommend getting a wipe holder with a weight on top to keep the wipes in place. I love our ubbi wipe dispenser. I also tried an itzy ritzy one and a travel ubbi dispenser they both also work well for only getting one wipe at a time until the wipes get low.

Bro, All I use for my kids are water wipes. 😂 they were the best for diaper rashes with my first as the other brands we tried left tacky residue behind. We never switched as a result.

I started with Honest wipes and around 4m my daughter got a rash that I couldn't resolve. Lasted over a month. It was the damn wipes. Switched to Water Wipes, never had a problem again. When my cousin's baby hit 4m, they also developed a rash that wouldn't heal from the Honest wipes!! They're SO DRYING!

I literally had to regift the multiple giant boxes of Huggies sensitive wipes I got at my baby shower because they gave my daughter a terrible rash that left her almost raw. We found Water Wipes work great for her and I will never even attempt to try another brand. Definitely worth the extra $, but I wish they'd improve their packaging. Nothing like fighting for your life to pull out a wipe.

Another plus for water wipes!! They are expensive but well worth it for us! Never give a rash, durable, wet enough but not too wet! I wouldn't use anything else

Water Wipes are the best! And available easily on Amazon. The only thing is that they are kind of annoying to get out of the packaging as is, but we have the OXO Tot dispenser and have no issues

My mom is a NICU nurse and strongly encouraged me to switch to water wipes from huggies natural care when my baby had a bad rash. She said they are the best, and now that I've been using them I agree! They are more annoying to get out of the package as others have said, but overall I'm happy with them.

Based on your list, here are my thoughts: Water wipe is my favorite wipe for at home because the wipe feels super smooth and durable but they don't travel well because of the package type. The only reason I don't buy them for "at home" use is because they're expensive and you can't get them as a refill so there's more plastic waste. For traveling I'd use Honest. They're also a decent wipe but they have a plastic closure on the package. The only weird thing about honest is for some reason you can never get just one out of the package. You either have to dig to get one or you get 2 or 3 at a time. What did I actually use? Huggies Natural Care Sensitive Baby Wipes Refill. They come in a big plastic bag so there's less waste and I put them in my wipes warmer at home. For traveling, I mostly use the Kirkland brand. They're big wipes and really durable but I've also used honest for travel when I get their diaper bundles. As you've probably noticed I'm focused on how well the wipe fits my lifestyle vs what's in the wipes. Sometimes I float between brands depending on what's on sale but I always use Huggies refill at home to reduce waste. If you're seriously concerned about what to buy get a small pack of all of them and see which one fits your lifestyle.

We use water wipes and are very satisfied with them. The only annoying thing: sometimes it's difficult to only grab one out of the package. Before we change the diaper I already pull a few out in advance.

We use Kirkland because we really like them and they're cheap and convenient since we shop at Costco. However, if money wasn't an issue we would use water wipes. They're ridiculously expensive so we only used them for the first week or two but they are great!

We used water wipes for the first 3/4 months and now we use pampers sensitive fragrance free. She hasn't had any adverse reactions to soaps, lotions, or diapers and has never even had a diaper rash so I was okay with switching from water wipes. They get to be super expensive compared to other brands and once you get towards the bottom of the pack they're super wet and stick together. My husband wasn't the biggest fan bc he felt like he had to use a lot of them

We recently bought a big pack of water wipes on prime day and they are a *nightmare* to get out of the package. Either you get one wipe that doesn't pull the beginning of the next one (especially great for poop diapers) or a lump of wipes even though you only need one. I'm using them myself now and bought different ones for baby.

I use the pampers aqua pure. I started with the brand water wipes and hate them. My baby has a sensitive booty, even the sensitive wipes hurt him, but the aqua pure have been great!

We started with WaterWipes and they gave our baby terrible nappy rash. We now use cloths (just a load of old T-shirts cut up and edges sewed) and a spray bottle of water. We used one single WaterWipe recently while out and it again triggered a rash, so we've switched to a spray water bottle and dry disposable wipes for travel.