Kirkland (Costco) Baby Wipes

I know you said not from Costco, but the Kirkland wipes would tick ALL of your boxes and are very affordable. I tried Huggies wipes, and there's no way I'm switching to that mess after using Kirkland - and this is coming from someone who loves to buy the high end brand stuff.

Not a bad batch! I had this issue too. Came to recommend Costco's Kirkland wipes. Best ever, hands down. And the price can't be beat.

The Kirkland ones are amazing! Large size, thick and good water content.

Actual Kirkland brand wipes, yes. They're big and thick, have tons in a package, and are a fantastic value. Those Rico brand ones that Costco also carries? Absolutely not. They're that stretchy texture with spots of thickness surrounded by super thin web. Hot garbage.

I used to work with infants in childcare and parents supplied their own wipes so I got to try out every brand over a long period of time. Kirkland wipes have always been my favourite!

Kirkland brand! I have a 2 year old and newborn and we use them for both, the only time my 2 year old had a diaper rash is when we had a pack of pampers sensitive wipes when traveling once.

Love Kirkland wipes! Bigger than some other brands and wetter too but not too wet

My youngest is 11 this month and I still buy Costco wipes, the unscented ones.

Kirkland wipes come out of the package so easily. One at a time with one hand!!

We always used the kirkand case from Costco. It was reasonably priced and we could have a pack in the diaper bag and both cars and the changing station and daycare, so it was cheaper, babies bum never has trouble with them. This time likely using cloth wipes with water.

We use Kirkland because we really like them and they're cheap and convenient since we shop at Costco. However, if money wasn't an issue we would use water wipes. They're ridiculously expensive so we only used them for the first week or two but they are great!

We use the Costco wipes too and they are great. Both kids have sensitive skin and these seem to do the best job of all the ones we have tried.

We use Costco wipes for out and about. But make homemade ones for home use. We struggled with diaper rash for most of the first couple months before finally identifying our top wipes and diapers. We really like the heft and moisture level of Costco wipes as the best we found, but ultimately we had the best luck with homemade...

I'm using Kirkland wipes. They are low in dermatitis/sensitizing causing ingredients. They are a good value. I do not trust one lawyer with unverified claims to make medical decisions. I do not have similar data on other wipe manufacturers. Please read the top comment on the thread you linked: https://www.reddit.com/r/ScienceBasedParenting/s/dISy0h0pXY Anyone can sue. They are suing on the basis of false advertising. PFAS are a contaminant, not an ingredient. You have PFAS in your tap water, in your blood, in your children's blood. Presence of PFAS is expected, frankly.

I just buy my wipes from costco 20 bucks for 900 of them and we've had no problems

Personally, Huggie wipes suuuuuuck. they just rip. can't even pull one out without it just giving me a shred of a wipe. Luckily my kid's weren't sensitive to any. I really do like the kirkland brand or target brand.

Based on your list, here are my thoughts: Water wipe is my favorite wipe for at home because the wipe feels super smooth and durable but they don't travel well because of the package type. The only reason I don't buy them for "at home" use is because they're expensive and you can't get them as a refill so there's more plastic waste. For traveling I'd use Honest. They're also a decent wipe but they have a plastic closure on the package. The only weird thing about honest is for some reason you can never get just one out of the package. You either have to dig to get one or you get 2 or 3 at a time. What did I actually use? Huggies Natural Care Sensitive Baby Wipes Refill. They come in a big plastic bag so there's less waste and I put them in my wipes warmer at home. For traveling, I mostly use the Kirkland brand. They're big wipes and really durable but I've also used honest for travel when I get their diaper bundles. As you've probably noticed I'm focused on how well the wipe fits my lifestyle vs what's in the wipes. Sometimes I float between brands depending on what's on sale but I always use Huggies refill at home to reduce waste. If you're seriously concerned about what to buy get a small pack of all of them and see which one fits your lifestyle.

Kirkland from Costco or Members Mark wipes from Sam's club have been our go to for over 2.5 years now!!

Pampers is my #1 for the reasons you described but I buy Kirkland because they're cheap and they work well. Huggies are the worst; they don't feel soft or wet enough and they rip like wet paper towel.

I tried Kirkland which are made by Huggies. I didn't like them because they don't have as much lubricant, so they don't glide well. Because I got them from Costco, I had to give away a whole lot...

You may have to experiment and see what works with your baby's skin. My kids skin gets rashes from the Kirkland wipes but the Pampers sensitive wipes haven't given us any problems.

Ouf. If you're looking for natural wipes and have been using water and cotton in the past, I would avoid Kirkland wipes at all costs. I was a big fan of Costco wipes until they discontinued their Kirkland brand cotton (blue package) baby wipes and changed over to the new Kirkland wipes made with Tenecel (which is a fiber and not cotton). That plus the phenoxyethanol and licorice root extract they contain make them really irritating to sensitive kiddos and newborns. I really like HealthyBaby wipes for sensitive kidos because of the 100% water and plant-based ingredients and because they are chlorine free...

We also returned the Kirkland wipes after finding they were burning