
I know this is a few months old, but FREESTYLE!!! They are TCF, EWG certified, super soft (softer than Millie Moon and Pampers Pure [I have not used Coterie, so I cannot compare softness levels with them]), and available on walmart.com! We cloth diaper 90-95% of the time, but do use disposables when out of the house, on vacation, or when wash days get off schedule.
TCF and EWG certified, softer than Millie Moon and Pampers Pure - enthusiastic endorsement for disposable choice alongside cloth
Freestyle is our absolute favorite brand. Kudos are also great. Coterie is decent as well. We also have liked Pura diapers, but at size 3, they no longer have wetness indicators, which I find only slightly annoying most of the time, but more problematic if baby is ill/dehydrated and we are trying to see if she has peed at all within a certain number of hours, as that's how the pediatrician's office tells you when to take baby to the ER for IV fluids. The Pura diapers also seem more prone to leaking urine when baby <is> well hydrated.
Absolute favorite brand over Kudos, Coterie, and Pura
We tried Freestyle after going down the EWG Verified diaper rabbit hole and I'm really happy with them. They're EWG Verified and total chlorine free so I felt better about the ingredients, but what actually sold me was the absorbency. We stopped having leaks at night after using them for a few months. They're also really soft and gentle on my baby's skin. She has sensitive skin and used to get rashes easily, and that's cleared up since using them.
EWG Verified and TCF - stopped nighttime leaks, cleared up sensitive skin rashes. Absorbency sold them.
Freestyle is amazing.
Simple but emphatic endorsement of brand quality
I couldn't tell the difference between freestyle and coterie and have completely switched over to using freestyle! Their wipes are awesome too
Indistinguishable from Coterie quality - completely switched, presumably at lower cost. Wipes also great.
I recommend freestyle! I hate honest diapers tbh. They feel so thin and rough to me. Also, no one ever mentioned this to me and I had to figure it out on my own… I don't recommend printed diapers. It makes it so hard to see the blue line indicator in the night. And some prints can look like poop or blood, which freaked both my partner and I out during sleep deprived changes (looking at Huggies smugglers)
Recommends over Honest which felt thin and rough - better material quality
When you start digging into "natural" disposables it gets confusing fast because so many brands use similar wording. What helped me was looking for clearer ingredient standards instead of just the label. We've used the Skin Shield diapers from Freestyle as a backup because they're ewg verified and total chlorine free, and that gave me more confidence in what's actually in them. For us it's been a good middle ground when we're not using cloth and still want something that feels thoughtfully made and holds up well.
EWG verified and TCF gives ingredient confidence - good middle ground between cloth and conventional, holds up well
Other top-rated baby diapers from Reddit