
Honestly the infant to toddler rockers would be my recommendation. I used the fisher price one through 5 kids. I've had one for 13 years and my kids still rock around in it (4, 5 and 7). We've also bought other ones in between but I found that they just didn't last as long for us - similar to the ones you posted they're only recommended for up to 20lbs. I had BIG babies so they definitely out grew those bouncers quickly.
Used through 5 kids over 13 years, kids still use at ages 4-7, outlasted other brands — extraordinary longevity testimonial
The snugapuppy is great! I had two swings, a second hand snugapuppy from Facebook market (found for $20) and a 100$ one from Walmart. My baby preferred snugapuppy because it laid back more than the Walmart one. It turns so it can swing side to side or front to back. Also has a mirror in the center of the mobile which my bub LOVED gazing at. It plugs in, I think it takes batteries too but idk I never used any if it did. Super easy to assemble and very cozy :)
Baby preferred it over $100 Walmart swing, loved the mirror, plugs in, 2-way swing, easy assembly — detailed positive with direct comparison
I second this. We had a mamaroo and tried other swings at friends and family's houses and LO was not interested in them. She liked the [snugabear](https://www.walmart.com/ip/Fisher-Price-Cradle-n-Swing-with-6-Speeds-Snugabear-Sweetie/944619350) we got super cheap off of Facebook marketplace. Every cousin we had visit really took to it as well. I think it's because the seat was deeper, so more cozy/womb like.
Baby preferred it over MamaRoo and other swings, deeper seat feels womb-like, multiple cousins also loved it — positive with specific feature explanation
I don't personally have this one. But a mom friend of mine does, and my LO absolutely hated it every-time we tried to put her in it whenever we hung out at her place. DH and I had the Fisher Price Sweet Snugapuppy Dreams Cradle n' Swing. And my LO loved it.
LO loved the Fisher-Price Snugapuppy while hating the MamaRoo — direct positive comparison naming specific model
The animal fisher price ones are good. We burned the motor out of a 4moms one lol so we got a fisherprice one used and we've had it for months and they love it.
Good, twins love it, lasted months after 4moms motor burned out — positive durability and value comparison
I have the much cheaper Fisher Price one. Both of my kids loved them 🤷♀️ I put my kid in my sisters baby Bjorn one when at her house and she liked that one too but didn't seem much different
Both kids loved it, tried BabyBjorn and didnt seem much different — positive value comparison suggesting comparable quality at lower price
We were given a Fisher Price hand me down swing. It has a weight capacity up to 35lb. Newborn looked so tiny in it but fills it nicely at 4 months now. It's nothing fancy, but it works. it takes up more floor space than other options but they're cheap and can be found on marketplace.
Works well, high weight capacity (35lb), affordable on marketplace — positive but notes its basic and takes up space