Nipple Cream
The best nipple creams and nursing balms recommended by Reddit parents for breastfeeding and pumping comfort
132 Reddit comments analyzed·Updated Jul 14, 2026
What Reddit says
r/ExclusivelyPumping·▲ 36
“I've been using the Earth Mama Nipple Butter. I didn't have a particular issue with the lanolin but I have NEVER had a cracked nip or pain when pumping for over 13 months while using it. Highly recommend.”
On Earth Mama Nipple Butter→r/moderatelygranolamoms·▲ 25
“Honestly, silverettes were 100x better than any nipple cream I used. Also loved the Lansinoh ice packs.”
On Silverettes Silver Nursing Cups→r/pregnant·▲ 7
“I've been using this one from Lasinoh. No noticable stains on shirts or bras but I primarily wear black bras. https://www.target.com/p/lansinoh-organic-nipple-balm-2oz/-/A-76462852”
On Lansinoh Lanolin Nipple Cream→Top Products
Ranked by community sentiment and discussion volume
Guides & Articles
In-depth reads from the Reddit research behind these picks
Frequently Asked Questions
I spend hours building these community-backed guides. If you find them helpful, shopping through these links supports this project at no extra cost to you. Thanks for helping a fellow mama out!