Breast Pumps
The best breast pumps recommended by Reddit for new moms, working moms, and exclusively pumping parents
154 Reddit comments analyzed·Updated May 6, 2026
What Reddit says
r/BabyBumps·▲ 55
“If you want a portable pump then the blue spectra. If you want a wearable then Eufy S1.”
On Eufy S1→r/newborns·▲ 43
“I love my Spectra v2 (the blue portable one, not the pink that has to be plugged into the wall). I also have the Medela Harmony hand pump, which is great for when I'm traveling, my last pump of the night, or when I just want to get a quick pump out. I also just ordered the Momcozy M5, but it hasn't arrived yet, so I can't speak to the quality.”
On Spectra S1/S2→r/ExclusivelyPumping·▲ 28
“I feel like this is hard to answer. Because they're so expensive, most people have ever only tried 1 or 2. For me, the Baby Buddha is the best portable pump, but the cups are a PITA to clean. The Willow 3.0 is so far working much better for me than the Elvie OG. But if you get the Elvie from Costco, you can actually return it.”
On Baby Buddha→Top Products
Ranked by community sentiment and discussion volume
Frequently Asked Questions
I spend hours building these community-backed guides. If you find them helpful, shopping through these links supports this project at no extra cost to you. Thanks for helping a fellow mama out!